Monday, 29 October 2012

50 Shades of Grayling

Right now, grayling are the species du jour.  However, during my childhood, grayling were considered to be a pest, taking up resources for trout.  I’ve always thought that they were beautiful creatures with their De Stijl, colouring: slate grey flanks with a large black and red fin.  Nowadays, ever eclectic fishermen are constantly on the hunt for truly wild fish. These pretty creatures, which have never been stocked, fit the bill perfectly. As ever ahead of his time, they were also Charles Ritz’s favourite fish and considered them most difficult to catch;

“If I had to classify fly fishermen, I should place the grayling fisherman in the first rank, then the trout fishermen of the chalk streams and, finally, the trout fishermen of other rivers”.
Charles Ritz,  A Flyfisher's Life
1st Shade
The first fish I ever caught was a grayling. I was maybe four, five, six or seven years old. I remember it well. My father had placed me on a wooden footbridge on the River Itchen. I was using the same rod he used as a boy and I had been told to be careful with it. He had tied on a Butcher for me; it’s an old fashioned sea trout fly tied with silver, black and red. I let my line float down stream and watched it glint amongst the emerald floating blankets of weed. I felt the fish take the hook. I remember my parents telling me to keep my rod up as I played it. I remember feeling really pleased with myself when my father netted it. It was my fish. My first fish and I had to eat ti and so it was duly despatched and barbecued the next day.

2nd Shade
I caught a really big grayling this season. I’m not normally one for boasting because I struggle sometimes with people who do because I don’t often believe them.  I’ve broken all my own rules as I have been telling everyone I know how big it was. I don’t expect you to believe me.  For all its size it was an easy fish to catch. After a gentle take and a hard, long fight in a fast current my father was able to net it into my inadequately sized scoop net. He also measured it. It was 21” long.

3rd Shade
Another big grayling. I caught this on the Eden with Mr Chips and NCA.  It was a hard earned fish on a difficult and hugely wet day.  In this instance, I remember the fish less and the fishing more. I had been guided skilfully all weekend and had failed to catch a fish. In the fading light NCA and I spotted the fins and tails of an active fish in a steadily rising river.  I sneaked a cast up to it and uncharacteristically didn’t bottle it and miss the rise.  Strangely, this grayling felt like a big trout it felt shakier on the line than it should. When I caught it, I could have have been a little disappointed, I was after one of the famously vicious Eden trout. I couldn’t have been more pleased and neither could have my companions.  It had really been a team effort to get this rather shoddy fisherwoman to catch something.

The Other Shades
I admit that I have been known to target grayling with the express purpose of removing them (but not killing them) so that I can get at a prized trout. It rarely works. On the whole I don’t like catching grayling, they feel too precious somehow. When they are young, they feel so skittish and flap so much it’s a bit like catching a pretty moth and trying to release it outdoors without crushing its wings.  When grayling get large and old, they shoal up together like war veterans in a rest home.  I can’t help but think they deserve their peace.  I’ve been trying to express how odd grayling are.  They are wild and precious but can be annoying getting in the way of catching their flashier, blonder cousin the trout.  To look at they appear to be at once ridiculously delicate but also solid and steady.  Grayling have many shades, they are hard to explain or understand.  Perhaps, this is why, piscatorial gentlemen of yore called them ladies.

The title of this post was courtesy of Philip Miles.  Top photograph and grayling caught and photographed by Dave Smith. Bottom Photograph by  Matt Eastham.  All hold copyright of their words and images. 


  1. Hi,

    I enjoyed reading your experiences on the enigmatic grayling (very inventive post title!).

    Grayling can indeed seem a delicate fish especially during the warmer months but are usually very fit this time of year and always swim away with plenty of vigour.

    I hope your love affair with grayling blossoms in time and you enjoy the pleasures of this piscatorial princess as much as I do!

    PS, Great blog!

  2. Downstream from a bridge! A butcher! The Itchen! You were brought up in a culture of piscatorial recidivism.

  3. Yes it was downstream with a butcher but from then on it was a method never repeated. At the time we were being urged to remove and kill all grayling. Now we appreciate what super sport they are. Still prefer trout though!

  4. Interesting trash novel analogy Polly. The Sun must be missing a headline writer!
    Seriously, that was a nice piece...and 21 inches! You're looking well over 3lb there lass!

  5. I liked your Big Girls blog. Gorgeous pictures as ever.

  6. This comment has been removed by the author.

  7. Everything written on this blogs amaze me a lot. First the title itself makes me smile since it reminds me of the book the " Fifty Shades of Grey" because I really love that book and lastly the whole content of this blog. I love the fact that you have shared your experience in fly fishing, I love reading blogs about it cause fly fishing is an adventure for me. Thanks!

    tennessee fly fishing

  8. I m excited for the Fifty Shades of Grey movie. and i watch Christian Grey's work it is pretty awesome to see on the screen Christian Grey

  9. I am awaiting for the releasing of the movie fifty shades.
    christian grey

  10. I can't wait for the movie. I loved the books. I should agree these are the best written books.
    Anastasia Steele

  11. I wish robert pettinson would cast as christian... and am also excited to see this book on reel.
    The Movie Fifty Shades Of Grey

  12. Thanks For sharing of 50-shades-of-grayling...
    Keep Sharing More!!!
    Fifty Shades Movie